02.11.2017 • News

Judge Reverses Another J&J Talc Verdict

(c) GVictoria/Shutterstock
(c) GVictoria/Shutterstock

A court in the US state of California has reversed a verdict against drugmaker Johnson & Johnson in the ongoing litigation over whether the company’s talc productions can be linked to cancer.

The judgment just announced reverses an award of $417 million on behalf of a woman who argued that routine use of the company’s talc product in intimate applications caused her ovarian cancer. The court has ordered a new trial.

Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Maren Nelson said the evidence presented at a three-week trial did not support a verdict of that magnitude. The decision came just days after an appeals court in St. Louis reversed a separate $72 million verdict against J&J.

Alogether, the drugmaker is facing 4,800 talc lawsuits across the US.  Prior to the latest appeal, verdicts worth more than $700 million in damages had been pronounced.

Reviewing all of the evidence in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, the best that can be said is that there was (and is) an ongoing debate in the scientific and medical community about whether talc more probably than not causes ovarian cancer and thus giving rise to a duty to warn," Judge Nelson wrote. “Clear and convincing evidence of malice is lacking," she added.

The news agency Reuters said attorneys for the plaintiff plan to appeal the latest verdict reversal.

In the $72 million case, a panel ruled that because of a Supreme Court decision earlier this year, the St. Louis court did not have jurisdiction to handle a claim from an out-of-state plaintiff.

Free Virtual Event

Batteries and Hydrogen: Competitors or Partners?
CHEManager Spotlight

Batteries and Hydrogen: Competitors or Partners?

17 September 2026 | Reserve your spot to learn where solid-state batteries and green hydrogen are headed—and how leading teams are turning them into scalable energy storage solutions.

Special Issue

Circular Plastics Economy
Explore the Future of Plastics

Circular Plastics Economy

This special CHEManager issue explores the industry’s pivotal shift towards a more sustainable, circular plastics value chain. Readers will find expert analysis and real-world solutions for today’s most pressing recycling and regulatory challenges.

most read